來賓:
律師 吳旭洲
律師 莊秀銘
司改會執行長 林峯正
資深媒體人 陳敏鳳
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhZ7H7-41w6oFpLwmQcFPgQJxR7ERjMiqqsBSVE0ICRl05fd1-QS-f4JBu2sm63lE01ntluAkcT-zM07wxzq5A3Stc-WsybdHr6V7oj4R08GcTThd6ziSdCuSrSPL6ZQ5Q_6p1jEFmRHRU/s400/cg02.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiTU8GbmdinZqGg_n81rmRj54H0IJQ4kCEsrjxY_K3bVN9JlihQNoe_VqaijHF1CIZ81eoTEwWHHvBKG9WI-RWk1Qw19Rv3rQfZDWIXv9Atd1vjEHbHklK4SBUWOwT-9HB8TEPPg3anWj0/s400/cg03.jpg)
檢方控告前總統陳水扁等14人侵占國務費、貪污、洗錢案,北院下午四點一審結果出爐!如何看待這次的判決結果?扁珍判決理由夠不夠充分?
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjISJmdCKsv5j1dYvt4jHG41vxqDSoLwZkI8-rxEu5MqugfdURI4nwYMScZd3Lg8y3dKS7A7SZ28xrYc2X_c3PmWonfzqr2A6rvWcG6B8MgIpTWaySu6mq6bQzzJP48Yc5zq0Y6uNWBU10/s400/cg11.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgLp_8UdMx-LlEOlyJDJKZYLGrH_fIGK1p4q36D_ts3FuCFfmbCTnS2GLcn8EmVaLo8jHV3y0cEj2GtUzMf6Sg5tZca1b9O0ljTvRyReW6BrSrdrHZps-XTof6btGInMvap0Bow5Rx9zmA/s400/cg12.jpg)
陳鎮慧免刑合不合理?馬永成20年林德訓16年會不會太重?
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEh6nJLCPocOtMXgD_X2IDx-tDQqNil2JWQv1PWCuSj-lwZ4Pp4WTMkOcUdmt23AhNphltEUXf9hTEZC5jCgHpWgn0eMkjm1W4oHzWaA7o8U6Rw0qGo80VTICEZClVdlyMHf-l7xzcyIvdM/s400/cg14.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjwsH4wi2y0yu7nqtBGXa5UHTr2T-lCf-Esnv9c7PPUPF-54ZDZsnFADFsTWUx_9y1RNvHCVTRsRoDIjz7Sc9wyOEms1Vrz1G97zYCmzvurhTLdNCChdwFO7jingHXxH70QYTP-ZVf6n-M/s400/cg13.jpg)
扁案偵審一年來,過程爭議不斷!包括是否違反偵查不公開原則?是否濫權羈押?案件審理是否違反法官法定原則?國務費與特支費如何認定?政治獻金是否存在對價關係?法律見解攻防不斷!如何解讀今日一審結果?
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj9cuQvcgMPof8lFup2FyF8UFO6aKNYYI2iWI86vkF4sXYRjwjoXlLxHa7s7fKwpcWMq7g5eYg4Lg4S5Zf_n85_jJIMoveALyP4FDFCq778nZSASNPWxUuCIDmwpsy9IDqI4mdrxAAf3Aw/s400/cg10.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj8F-iXBv4tIGTpkd36TKKu3Ln9m2z4DjosIA2WDTgPSanjftlg-efHAnuUZyNfbHihzoiRCB1JZCO56ZFcqak0Q4SCu_5XROazXmTQA9KzNSzfqSEAweYm1RbE82Ma3tJVIlIOSpU38vU/s400/cg09.jpg)
風波到此為止?司法大戰才要開始?會不會引發後續的政治效應?
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEijVhtfq8kIOXE2Oo1tlA3jAbpSbTzgweLAhjrNlkkhNuYDX4EN9OYL5OlDw5_3FCgFajiJMMGmUNGWjdmY83KyqydeyIaIESL4bY-a5fOCbGyHxmabblhooo3KgzctqEBjkxHxEXKY7E4/s400/cg08(1).jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhpt3LUERf6c5iMAba1qF2RDiKrszVp5z-ysC9uqb_lN0C4rCnqglOgDvxXDzv_0PeebWKc-4ULYB1Vzg8DxzhWpWs3vGgE3MC671QxRMYK6YhhcOp9r5YNThRSWfOTze4DSHjZWQyFkLI/s400/cg07(1).jpg)
扁辦:此次偵審過程是政治追殺?有理嗎?扁辦所指的爭議有哪些?羈押一年多,違反人權?從重從寬,法官自由心證?裁量權有多大?
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgmP0Jy8ZAy3mvYh53WU11WAt8Jq3U-GCKK_WS9IiL4Zh3CjIFDU1LYIrgb0VdaZ2IyAbV4UPau5eXitFe5OVMn9wGHCjupWv_pYFnJpHN5Epkr34mx2Ns1ZZm9BEEPLWJ8zh__jaUETq8/s400/cg06.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjmKWf7GAuJRDKj1s4aRAPRgDFJqrf3BLnn14Qfzrgm7RUqw-d9YgstKxS4L-I0ydZlFT4XYKi6M87lPUD02Xp1fe8brycaqJCsFlU5W1K_hUNdi_EQI914sMewx2T_asm6W0_r0ZXzszk/s400/cg05(1).jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjdlxTeo3z3lBSTOdsbuZW6w0B_nEP9q45b22PxbntwD3tC059f2lAxeC9eRBoGkMRZQqLZgBCf2AvMCQvXjdVm0LxVUjY7BSDHBdE6bos_xkw_ByPPb10lp3brtUgX4fYiRF5A7j9MbCQ/s400/cg04.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhJ3VWpYNfvM269lNOzuJ4ypo2zCosMb92UiAXgSJkFJrWWTHEX2haRTQopTCS2SQI1s8Tka1vOWf5CKHPHik7m5q6H2KNUo7rHdsDa4Lc4UC8_YRszfKTrMcZZoiwW9hMGMKEh1id5upI/s400/cg01.jpg)
台灣從這次扁案得到什麼?失去什麼?司法能否再進步?政治人物能否作為警惕?司法能否作為社會正義的最後且堅固防線?